When Missing the Point is the Point: The U.S. Civil Rights Commission Demonstrates Why We Have Recusal Norms

In 2013, after the Obama Administration's Department of Education issued the first of three "guidance" letters related to the application of Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to allegations of sexual harassment or sexual violence on college campuses, the United States Civil Rights Commission (America’s statutory guardian of civil rights since 1957) decided to undertake a narrow investigation into the conflict between the First Amendment and free expression, on the one hand, and sexual harassment law as applied on campus, on the other. But a funny thing happened between that decision and the Commission’s release, in January of 2020, of its related report seven years later. Catherine Lhamon, the Assistant Secretary of Education for Civil Rights who oversaw the preparation of at the last two of those rounds of “guidance[,]” became the Chairman of the Commission. And Chairman Lhamon had no interest in recusing herself from “grading” Assistant Secretary Lhamon’s previous work. No, instead, she oversaw the production of the Commission’s final report, published over her signature, with the odd title of “Free to Learn: Speech and Sexual Harassment on Campus[.]” Chairman Lhamon, sitting in judgment of Assistant Secretary Lhamon, assured that the Commission would laud her efforts and endorse the policies she implemented in her previous role.  Missing the point that those policies reduced the civil rights of Americans (both those accused and those too afraid to speak lest they be accused of harassment) was the point.  And the fact that, under Ms. Lhamon’s guidance, the Commission would take that stance demonstrates exactly why it is that America has norms requiring parties not to be their own judges, even where, as here, no law expressly forbids it.